Robert Besser
29 Apr 2025, 15:56 GMT+10
WASHINGTON, D.C.: This week, U.S. Supreme Court justices seemed open to letting fuel companies challenge California's strict vehicle emissions and electric car rules. These rules are more challenging than the federal ones and are meant to fight climate change.
The case involves fuel company Valero and other industry groups. They are appealing a lower court's decision that they didn't have the legal right to sue. The Supreme Court justices—both conservative and liberal—asked questions that suggested they might allow the lawsuit to go forward.
The issue centers on a special rule that lets California set its own more demanding vehicle standards. Typically, states have to follow national regulations, but under the Clean Air Act, California can get permission from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to do more. This permission called a "waiver," was given back to California by the Biden administration in 2022 after being taken away by the Trump administration in 2019.
The fuel companies say the EPA went too far and hurt their business by lowering demand for gasoline. Their lawyer argued that the government is unfairly favoring electric vehicles, making it harder for fuel producers to compete.
Justice Elena Kagan said it seems easy to show that the rules hurt the fuel industry. She also pointed out that both the EPA and California have said their rules are meant to reduce gasoline use, which supports the fuel companies' argument.
Much of the court's discussion focused on whether it's "common sense" to say that California's rules will push carmakers to build more electric vehicles and fewer gas-powered ones. Conservative Justice Amy Coney Barrett said proving that doesn't seem too difficult.
California has had over 75 such waivers since 1967, and its rules have helped push the market toward cleaner cars. The 2022 waiver lets the state set stricter pollution rules and require more zero-emission vehicles through 2025.
The Supreme Court is expected to decide the case by June.
In recent years, the court has often limited the EPA's power. It has ruled against the agency in other cases involving clean air and water rules, including a 2024 decision that blocked a rule aimed at reducing air pollution between states.
Get a daily dose of Illinois Intelligencer news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Illinois Intelligencer.
More InformationTOKYO, Japan: Toyota's overseas sales surged to a new March record, driven largely by a rush of North American buyers ahead of newly...
(250429) -- SHIJIAZHUANG, April 29, 2025 (Xinhua) -- A student from the United States learns Chinese calligraphy during a study tour...
The US president has said bypassing the constitutional limit in 2028 would be a hard thing to do US President Donald Trump has ruled...
Ottawa [Canada], April 29 (ANI): Pro Khalistani, Canadian politician and New Democratic Party (NDP) chief Jagmeet Singh has announced...
Ottawa [Canada], April 29 (ANI): The Liberal Party is projected to secure a fourth consecutive term in Canada's federal election, a...
Washington DC [US], April 29 (ANI): Screenwriter Bob Gale has quashed any possible speculations of the creation of 'Back To The Future'...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: This week, U.S. Supreme Court justices seemed open to letting fuel companies challenge California's strict vehicle...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: The Trump administration announced this week that it will create a fast-track approval process for energy and mining...
JERUSALEM - More than 80 ambassadors and heads of mission from across the world were addressed by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: U.S. lawmakers are turning up the heat on China's biggest telecom firms, issuing subpoenas to compel their cooperation...
BRUSSELS, Belgium: European pharmaceutical companies are pushing for higher drug prices across the EU, warning that current pricing...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: A nuclear power plant in Michigan is hoping to become the first in the U.S. to restart after being permanently shut...